Skip to main content

What if governments make their own crypto?

CBDC meme

Is this the future we want for humanity?

They're very welcome to, but it will only hasten free-market crypto's rise.

Many governments have raised the idea of their own cryptocurrency, a "Central Bank Digital Currency" (CBDC), but to date none of them have come to much.

Consider the following problems a government has when launching its own cryptocurrency:

  • Legitimising competition: Governments launching their own cryptocurrency legitimizes the idea of private cryptocurrencies to their entire citizenry, and helps to popularise them as alternatives to government fiat or digital currency.
  • Misaligned incentives: A government is undoubtedly going to build in taxation controls, spending limits, privacy invading tracking, lack of interoperability with other cryptocurrencies or other anti-consumer "features" that most or all of their citizens will not want, and which free market cryptocurrencies do not have.
  • Brutal competiton: The cryptocurrency market is absolutely cut-throat and exploding with innovation. A CBDC is going to be swept aside in a tide of decentralised productivity. In the same way that no single government could make a better national Internet that outcompeted the global Internet, no country will be able to make a cryptocurrency that can innovate, improve and attract as much human talent as the large free market cryptocurrencies can, let alone the combined global pool of private market cryptocurrencies.
  • Other Priorities: Similar to trying to ban cryptocurrencies, governments are way too busy with all the other things that need their attention to fight this battle. Creating and running a cryptocurrency is no small task, let alone all the surrounding infrastructure (wallets, marketing, payment systems, browser plugins etc. etc.), and it would be a huge drain on government time, money and attention that would still be inferior to just allowing private cryptocurrencies to flourish - which is free for the government to do.

See also: What if governments ban/regulate crypto?